Most meal delivery comparisons rank services by price or overall score. But if taste is your main priority — if you want to actually enjoy eating the food, not just hit a budget or a macro target — the ranking looks quite different. The highest-rated service isn't always the best tasting, and the best-tasting meal kit in Australia has a surprisingly low overall score.
Taste vs overall score — they're not the same thing
A service's overall ProductReview score reflects delivery reliability, customer service, value for money, and experience — not just food quality. Marley Spoon scores 3.0/5 overall because of billing and subscription issues, but its food consistently receives the best taste reviews of any meal kit. Understanding this gap is key to finding what you actually want.
Best tasting meal kits
1. Marley Spoon — Best tasting meal kit in Australia
- Chef-designed recipes — not just convenient, genuinely cookable
- 300+ rotating catalogue — far less recipe repetition than competitors
- More complex techniques: proper searing, reduction sauces, fresh aromatics
- Ingredient quality rated higher than HelloFresh and EveryPlate in reviews
- Customers who've tried multiple services consistently rank it #1 for taste
- 3.0/5 overall score — the lowest of any meal kit on our site
- Billing and cancellation complaints are frequent
- Use a credit card with easy dispute capability before subscribing
- Start with a short trial — don't commit to a long subscription upfront
2. HelloFresh — Most consistent tasting meal kit
HelloFresh won't win a taste competition against Marley Spoon, but its recipes are well-tested and reliably good. With 50+ options per week there's enough variety to avoid fatigue, and the quality is consistent — you're not going to get a bad week. For most households, this balance of good taste and operational reliability makes HelloFresh the practical choice.
Read full review → vs EveryPlateEveryPlate and Dinnerly are solid budget options but not the ones to choose if taste is the priority. Simplified recipes, fewer ingredients per dish, and straightforward flavour profiles — good value, but not the most exciting cooking experience.
Best tasting prepared meals
Prepared meals face a structural taste challenge: food gets cooked, chilled or frozen, then reheated — which affects texture and flavour. The services that score best on taste are the ones that work hardest against that constraint: no preservatives, quality ingredients, and cooking techniques designed to survive reheating.
1. Chefgood — Closest to home-cooked of any prepared meal service
- No artificial preservatives, fillers or flavour enhancers
- Fresh, locally sourced ingredients — quality starts at the source
- Chef-prepared with real cooking techniques
- "Closest to home-cooked" is the most common description in reviews
- Customer service complaints in some reviews
- No delivery to TAS
- Fewer reviews than larger services (1,313)
2. Soulara — Best tasting vegan prepared meals
A telling pattern in Soulara's reviews: even customers writing negative feedback about delivery or service often say the food was excellent. Curries, grain bowls and noodle dishes are the most praised. For plant-based cooking in particular, the flavour depth is genuinely hard to match with other prepared meal services.
Read full review → Best vegan guide3. Dineamic — Best tasting high-performance meals
Dineamic is the best-rounded option if you want both taste and nutrition — it's the only service on this list that also has the highest overall score (4.5/5). Founded by an AFL player and a dietitian, the brand's starting point was performance food that actually tastes good, not nutrition at the expense of enjoyment.
Read full review →Full taste ranking
| Service | Type | Taste verdict | Overall score | Price from |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Marley Spoon | Meal kit | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Best of any kit | 3.0/5 ⚠ | ~$9/srv |
| HelloFresh | Meal kit | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Reliable & consistent | 4.1/5 | $8.75/srv |
| EveryPlate | Meal kit | ⭐⭐⭐ Good for the price | 4.3/5 | $4.44/srv |
| Chefgood | Prepared | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Closest to home-cooked | 4.1/5 | $10.95/meal |
| Soulara | Prepared | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Best plant-based taste | 4.1/5 | $10.95/meal |
| Dineamic | Prepared | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Best taste + best score | 4.5/5 ⭐ | $11.95/meal |
Compare all meal delivery services
Prices, scores and delivery areas in one table.
Open comparator →