Comparison
HelloFresh vs Dinnerly Australia 2026 — Which Is Worth It?
By Tasty Food Box
·
Updated June 2026
·
Scores from ProductReview.com.au
HelloFresh and Dinnerly are two very different meal kit services in Australia — one is the market leader with nearly 19,000 reviews, the other is a budget-tier brand with serious service complaints. The core question: is saving $2–3 per serving worth the trade-off in reliability?
After reviewing the data from over 20,000 verified Australian customers, our answer is clear. For the vast majority of households, HelloFresh is the better choice. Here's why.
Caution — Dinnerly score below threshold
Dinnerly holds a 3.2/5 score on ProductReview.com.au, below our 3.5 caution threshold. The most common complaints include missing ingredients, late deliveries, and charges continuing after customers have cancelled. Read recent reviews before subscribing.
Price — where Dinnerly has the edge
Price per serving
HelloFresh
From $8.75/serving
Dinnerly
From $5.99/serving
Cheaper
2 people, 3 meals/week
Dinnerly
~$35.94/week
Save ~$16/week
Dinnerly is cheaper per serving — that much is clear. But it's worth noting that EveryPlate is cheaper still at $4.44/serving and carries a 4.1/5 score. If price is your main driver, EveryPlate beats Dinnerly on both cost and reliability.
Customer scores — a dramatic difference
ProductReview score
HelloFresh
4.1 / 5 · 18,672 reviews
Much higher
Dinnerly
3.2 / 5 · 1,010 reviews
Positive sentiment
HelloFresh
~79% positive reviews
Stronger record
Dinnerly
~62% positive reviews
The score difference between HelloFresh (4.1/5) and Dinnerly (3.2/5) is not marginal — it's substantial. HelloFresh has nearly 19 times as many reviews, giving its score much stronger statistical weight. Dinnerly's complaints cluster around delivery failures and billing issues, which are particularly frustrating for a weekly subscription service.
Recipe variety and format
Weekly recipes
HelloFresh
50+ recipes per week
Far more choice
Dinnerly
~25 recipes per week
Recipe cards
HelloFresh
Printed cards included in every box
More convenient
Dinnerly
Digital only — no printed cards, app or website access required
Pantry staples
HelloFresh
Most pantry items pre-portioned and included
Dinnerly
Minimal inclusions — oil, salt, butter not included
Dinnerly's digital-only recipe format is one of its most debated trade-offs. To keep costs down, Dinnerly doesn't include printed recipe cards — you access instructions via their app or website while cooking. For households without a tablet or stand-up phone holder in the kitchen, this creates friction. HelloFresh's laminated recipe cards are part of the experience and eliminate this issue.
Delivery coverage
States covered
HelloFresh
All 7 states — NSW, VIC, QLD, WA, SA, ACT, TAS
Wider coverage
Dinnerly
6 states — NSW, VIC, QLD, WA, SA, ACT
No TAS delivery
Parent company — Marley Spoon Group
Dinnerly is owned by Marley Spoon Group, the same parent company behind Marley Spoon Australia. Both Dinnerly and Marley Spoon carry below-average ProductReview scores — Dinnerly at 3.2/5 and Marley Spoon at 3.0/5. The shared ownership means similar infrastructure and some overlapping complaints (billing after cancellation, missing ingredients).
Who wins overall?
Choose by your situation
Best overall
HelloFresh — superior score, wider coverage, printed recipe cards, 50+ recipes per week. Safer choice for most households.
On a tight budget
Consider
EveryPlate before Dinnerly — it's cheaper ($4.44/srv vs $5.99) and has a 4.1/5 score, far ahead of Dinnerly's 3.2/5.
In Tasmania
HelloFresh only — Dinnerly does not deliver to TAS.
Want digital recipes
Dinnerly — if you prefer accessing recipes on your phone, and understand the reliability trade-off.
Experienced cook
HelloFresh — broader recipe range and dietary filter options including Low Calorie and Carb Smart.
Full side-by-side comparison
|
HelloFresh |
Dinnerly |
| Price from |
$8.75/serving |
$5.99/serving |
| ProductReview score |
4.1 / 5 |
3.2 / 5 ⚠ |
| Number of reviews |
18,672 |
1,010 |
| Recipes per week |
50+ |
~25 |
| Recipe cards |
Printed, included |
Digital only |
| Pantry staples |
Most included |
Not included |
| Delivery states |
All 7 (incl. TAS) |
6 (no TAS) |
| Delivery fee |
$9.99/box |
$9.99/box |
| Skip/pause |
Yes |
Yes (read terms) |
| Cancel anytime |
Yes |
Yes (read terms) |
| Parent company |
HelloFresh Group |
Marley Spoon Group |
Compare all meal kits side by side
HelloFresh, EveryPlate, Dinnerly and Marley Spoon — all in one view.
Open comparison tool →
Frequently asked questions
Is Dinnerly cheaper than HelloFresh in Australia?
Yes. Dinnerly starts from $5.99 per serving vs HelloFresh at $8.75 per serving. However, EveryPlate is even cheaper at $4.44 per serving and carries a far better customer score (4.1/5 vs Dinnerly's 3.2/5), making it a stronger budget alternative to HelloFresh.
Are Dinnerly and Marley Spoon the same company?
Yes. Dinnerly is owned and operated by Marley Spoon Group. They share infrastructure but operate as separate brands — Dinnerly is positioned as the budget tier and Marley Spoon as the premium tier. Both carry below-average ProductReview scores (Dinnerly 3.2/5, Marley Spoon 3.0/5).
Is Dinnerly worth it in Australia?
For most Australians, Dinnerly is not the best choice. Its 3.2/5 ProductReview score is below our 3.5 caution threshold, and the most common complaints include missing ingredients, late deliveries, and charges continuing after cancellation. If budget is your priority, EveryPlate at $4.44/serving offers a better experience at a lower price.
Does Dinnerly deliver to Tasmania?
No. Dinnerly does not deliver to Tasmania. It covers NSW, VIC, QLD, WA, SA and ACT only. HelloFresh delivers to all 7 Australian states and territories, including Tasmania.
Can you pause Dinnerly?
Dinnerly allows you to skip weeks or pause your subscription, but several verified reviewers on ProductReview report difficulty managing their account and unexpected charges after attempting to pause or cancel. Read the subscription terms carefully before signing up and consider using a credit card that allows easy dispute resolution.